175. University of Dublin & Trinity College, Dublin 1920
App. 10 March 1920. Rep. 12 Nov 1920, Cmd.1078, xiii, 1189. Evidence: 1921,
Cmd.1167, xi. Cost £254.
Sir A. Geikie; Sir J. Ross; A.E. Shipley; J.S.E. Townsend; J. Joly.
Secretary: G. Waterhouse. (Professor of German at University of Dublin; named
To consider the application made by the University of Dublin for financial
assistance from the State, and to enquire into, and make recommendations upon,
the financial resources, administration and constitution of the University and of
176. Fire Brigades 1921-23
App. 19 Jan 1921. Rep. 20 July 1923, Cmd.1945, xi, 167. Evidence: Non P.P.,
HO, 1922. Est. cost £3,081.
Hon. Sir P.M. Laurence; Sir J.E. Petavel; Sir S. Sladen; Sir V.H.P. Caillard; Sir
M. Fitzmaurice; A.L. Dixon; G. Symonds; V.L. Henderson; J.T. Burns; H. Peters;
Secretary: J.C. MacIver. (Home Office)
Further Warrants of 2 Feb 1921 added F. Caldwell, C.F. De Salis, R.
M'Connell, and of 11 Apr 1921 D.L. Solomon to the Commission. Caillard
resigned 31 May 1921, due to lack of time to attend meetings, and was not
To inquire into existing provision for (1) the avoidance of loss from fire and (2)
the extinction of outbreaks of fire, due regard being paid to considerations of
economy as well as of efficiency.
All signed the report but only Petavel and Henderson signed without adding
Treasury files contain considerable amounts of detail about this Commission,
largely concerning their efforts to block it. They considered the Home Office
had 'behaved very badly about the appointment of this Royal Commission';
neither the terms of reference nor the personnel, nor the estimated cost had been
approved by the Treasury. The Home Office had sought to justify this omission
on the grounds that the Commission had been decided upon before receipt of a
Treasury Circular (F.2355, 17 Dec 1920) which required Treasury sanction for
committees which were likely to involve considerable expenditure; but 'the
necessity for economy did not start with this Treasury Circular and in any case
the Home Office should have sought our previous approval for a Commission,
the cost of which is to fall on our Vote'. (S.D. Waley to O.E. Niemeyer, 22 Feb
The Commission, through its Secretary, applied for a higher rate of expenses for
its members when they were away from home, citing as precedent the
Commission on Reparations (see no. 178) whose members received two guineas
per head per night rather than the usual twenty-five shillings. This was refused
on the grounds that the two Commissions were qualitatively different: the
Reparations Commission (like the Defence of the Realm Losses Commission)
was considered to be a quasi-judicial body 'expected to function for some time
or to perform duties which would naturally carry some remuneration. They are
not entirely parallel with an ordinary Commission appointed to do a
comparatively short job, membership of which is intended to carry its own
reward'. (Treasury memo., 29 June 1921) This was conveyed in the Chancellor's
formal reply to the Home Secretary of 2 July 1921. (PRO.T.160/49/E3730)
177. Importation of Livestock 1921
App. 11 May 1921. Rep. 30 Aug 1921, Cmd.1139, 1541, xviii. Est. cost £1,601.
Viscount Finlay; Lord Askwith; Sir A.F. Firth; Sir A.E. Shipley; Sir W.H. Peat.
Secretary: A.W. Cockburn. (Barrister)
To inquire into the admission into the United Kingdom of livestock for purposes
other than immediate slaughter at the ports; and its effects on domestic supplies.
178. Reparation Grants 1921-24
App. 15 Aug 1921. Rep. (1) 22 Jan 1923, Cmd.1798, x, 973; (2) 26 Feb 1924,
Cmd.2066, ix, 249. Other papers: Non P.P., 1923; 1925; 1926; 1927; 1928;
1929; 1930. Est. cost £2,586.
Lord Sumner; W.E. Home; J.H. Sabin.
Secretary: J.S. Gardner (Lawyer, Reparation Claims Dept); resigned Sept 1922;
succ. by K.W. Blaxter.
Sabin died 16 March 1922 and was replaced by Sir J.H. Oakley in a Warrant of
20 May 1922.
To consider cases where there was a moral claim by British Nationals for
compensation for sufferings or damage arising out of the action of the enemy
during the War within Annex 1 to Part 8 of the Treaty of Versailles.
PRO.T.160/88/F3243 gives details of way in which the terms of reference were
drawn up; it was emphasised that moral claims were to have more weight than
the extent of damage; and that the Commission should not be too legal in
179. London Government 1921-23
App. 24 Oct 1921. Rep. 27 Feb 1923, Cmd.1830, xii, Pt.1, 567. Evidence: Non
P.P., Min. of Health, 1923; 1924. Est. cost £3,032.
Viscount Ullswater; Sir R.V. Vassar-Smith; Sir H.C. Monro; Sir A. Gray; E.H.
Hiley; G.J. Talbot; N. Chamberlain; R. Donald; E.R. Turton; S. Walsh.
Secretary: M Heseltine. Asst. Sec: J.A. Lawther. (Both of Min. of Health.)
Vassar-Smith resigned Dec 1921, and Chamberlain in Nov 1922; neither was
To inquire and report what, if any, alterations are needed in the local
government of the administrative county of London and the surrounding districts,
with a view to securing greater efficiency and economy in the administration of
local government services and to reducing any inequalities which may exist in the
distribution of local burdens as between different parts of the whole area. (In
The majority report was signed by Ullswater, Monro and Turton, and by Gray,
subject to a memorandum, and there were two minority reports: the first signed
by Hiley and Talbot; and the second by Donald and Walsh.
PRO.HLG.9/2/91002 contains correspondence and papers relating to the
appointment of the Commission, including copies of letters to potential members,
and from people who wished to be considered as members.
180. Honours System 1922
App. 16 Sept 1922. Rep. 22 Dec 1922: 1923 Cmd.1789, xi, 975. Cost £31.10s.
Lord Dunedin; Duke of Devonshire; Lord Denman; A. Henderson; Sir E. Cecil;
Sir S.J.G. Hoare; Sir G.C. Marks.
Secretary: J. Rae.
To advise on the procedure to be adopted in future to assist the Prime Minister
in making recommendations to the monarch of names of persons deserving
special honour. (In full.)
Henderson did not sign and wrote a Dissent to the report, to which the other
members attached a reply.
181. Local Government 1923-29
App. 14 Feb 1923. Rep. (1) 7 Aug 1925: 1924-25, Cmd.2506, xiv, 479; (2) 9 Oct
1928: 1928-29, Cmd.3213, viii, 25; (3) 12 Nov 1929: 1929-30, Cmd.3436, xv,
593. Evidence: Non P.P., Min. of Health, 1923; 1924; 1925; 1928; 1929; 1930.
Est. cost £11,982.
Earl of Onslow; Lord Strachie; Sir G.M.W. Macdonogh; Sir W.R.D. Adkins; Sir
W. Middlebrook; Sir L. Beard; Sir W.P. Nicholas; W.R.B. Riddell; E.H. Lloyd;
A.M. Myers (ktd. 1924); H.G. Pritchard; E.R. Turton; J.L.V.S. Williams.
Secretary: M. Heseltine; succ. by P. Barter, Apr 1928. Asst. Secs: J.A. Lawther
and J.D. Castle. (All of Min. of Health.)
Warrants of 5 March 1925 appointed S. Taylor in place of Dent Adkins who died
30 Jan 1925; of 7 June 1926 appointed J. Bond in place of Powell Nicholas who
died 10 Apr 1926; of 19 Oct 1926 appointed H.C. Norman in place of Myers
who died 9 Oct 1926. Lloyd resigned 14 March 1928 and Turton died 9 May
1929; neither was replaced. The terms of reference were extended to bring
Parish councils and Parish meetings within the scope of the inquiry by a Warrant
of 4 Aug 1926.
To enquire into existing law and procedure relating to the extension of County
Boroughs and the creation of new County Boroughs in England and Wales; the
effects of this on existing Councils; to investigate relations between Local
Authorities and make general recommendations as to their constitution, areas and
PRO.HLG.8/2/91001 records Treasury concern over the appointment of the
Commission. O.E. Niemeyer to the Minister of Health (26 March 1923) pointed
out that as Treasury sanction for the Commission had not been obtained before
its approval by the King no provision had been made for its expenses in the
1923-24 Estate, and asked that 'the most rigid economy may be enforced in every
detail of their work'. The file contains both the subsequent submissions of
estimated costs from the Commission as well as Treasury responses, and includes
details of their struggle to obtain Treasury approval for the use of a press cutting
service at a cost not to exceed three guineas.
PRO.HO.45/156/442222 gives details of the appointment of the Commission and
correspondence relating to the legal implications of its recommendations.
182. Mining Subsidence 1923-27
App. 15 June 1923. Rep. (1) 21 Dec 1925: 1926, Cmd.2570, xiii, 807; (2) 23
June 1927, Cmd. 2899, xi, 303. Evidence: Non P.P., Mines Dept., 1923; 1924;
1925. Est. cost £3,758.
Viscount Chelmsford; W. Adamson; Sir W.P. Nicholas; G.A. Lewis; G.C.H.
Wheler; V. Hartshorn; H.R. Buchanan; R.G. Ellis; H. Jevons; H. Louis; M.F.
Maclean; R.F. MacSwinney; F.B. Varley; J.D. Wallis.
Secretary: W.G. Nott-Bower. (Mines Dept.) Asst. Sec: G.C. North. (Min. of
A Warrant of 17 March 1924 appointed Lord Blanesburgh as chairman and E.
Morrell and J.C. Welsh as Commissioners in place of Napier, Adamson and
Hartshorn who resigned. Powell Nicholas resigned due to ill health shortly
before his death in 1926.
To consider the operation of the law relating to the support of the surface of the
land by underlying or adjacent minerals ... to enquire into the extent and gravity
of the damage caused by subsidence owing to the extraction of minerals, and to
report what steps should be taken by legislation or otherwise to remedy any
defects or hardships.
183. Superior Civil Service in India 1923-24
App. 15 June 1923. Rep. 27 March 1924, Cmd.2128, viii, 607.
Viscount Lee of Fareham; Sir R.H. Craddock; Sir C. Jackson; Sir C.H. Setalvad;
Khan Bahadur Sir M. Habibullah; Rai Bahadur H.K. Kaul; D. Petrie; B. Basu;
Joint Secretaries: S.F. Stewart (Indian Office) and A.W. Street.
Setalvad resigned 22 Oct 1923 and was replaced on 26 Oct 1923 by N.M.
To enquire into and make recommendations on (1) the organisation and general
conditions of service, financial and otherwise of the superior Civil Services in
India; (2) the possibility of transferring any of their present duties and functions
to services constituted on a provincial basis; (3) provisions under the Government
of India Act for the recruitment of Europeans and Indians.
The report was signed subject to a note by Basu.
184. National Health Insurance 1924-26
App. 11 July 1924. Rep. 22 Feb 1926, Cmd.2596, xiv, 311. Evidence: Non P.P.,
Min. of Health, 1925; 1926. Est. cost £3,831.
Lord Lawrence of Kingsgate; Sir J. Anderson; Sir H.D. Rolleston; Sir A.W.
Watson; Sir A. Worley; Sir A.R. Duncan; A.D. Besant; F. Bramley; J. Cook; J.
Evans; A. Gray; W. Jones; Mrs F.N.H. Bell; Miss G.M. Tuckwell.
Secretary: E. Hackforth. (Min. of Health) Asst. Sec: J.W. Peck. (Scottish Bd. of
Bramley resigned because of illness 11 March 1925, and was not replaced.
To inquire into the scheme of National Health Insurance established by the
National Health Insurance Acts, 1911-22, and to report what, if any, alterations,
extensions or developments should be made in regard to the scope of that scheme
and the administrative, financial and medical arrangements set up under it. (In
The majority report was signed subject to reservations by Duncan and Gray; the
minority report was signed by Cook, Evans, Mrs Harrison Bell and Miss
PRO.PIN.4/203: Misc. Papers includes typescripts of some of the evidence and
statements received by the Commission with a list of names, and brief details of
the letters received. Some of these are from groups and associations but many
are from individual members of the public and cover a wide range of topics from
suggestions about the inclusion of slaughtermen under the National Insurance Act
(from J. Mortimer, 14 July 1924) to proposals for a dowry for women at
marriage (from Mrs H. Blake, 1 Oct 1924).
185. Lunacy and Mental Disorder 1924-26
App. 25 July 1924. Rep.7 July 1926, Cmd.2700, xiii, 373. Evidence: Non P.P.,
Min. of Health, 1926. Est. cost £2,386.
H.P. Macmillan; Earl Russell; Lord E.S.C. Percy; Sir H.D. Rolleston; Sir T.
Hutchison (d. 12 Apr 1925); Sir E.V. Hiley; Sir D. Drummond; W.A. Jowitt;
F.D. MacKinnon; H. Snell; Mrs A. Mathew; Miss M.J. Symons.
Secretary: P. Barter. (Min. of Health) Asst. Sec: W. Fairley. (Bd. of Control)
A Warrant of 13 Nov 1924 appointed N. Micklem in place of MacKinnon who
had resigned on his appointment as a Justice of the High Court. Lord Percy also
resigned in Nov 1924 when he was appointed President of the Board of
Education, and was not replaced.
(1) To enquire as regards England and Wales into the existing law and
administrative machinery in connection with the certification, detention and care
of persons who are or are alleged to be of unsound mind; (2) To consider as
regards England and Wales the extent to which provision is or should be made
for the treatment wihtout certification of persons suffering from mental disorder;
And to make recommendations. (In full.)
The Commission was established soon after the case of Harnett v. Bond and
Adam when Mr Justice Lush found that Harnett had been wrongfully detained
under the current lunatic laws. Following a number of questions by MPs during
March and April 1924, including one from Lady Astor asking if the inquiry
would include 'a capable woman' (Hansard, 3 March 1924), Treasury approval
was granted on 31 May 1924. (PRO.T.160/196) The Commission was given
additional powers to summon witnesses and hear evidence on oath under the
Tribunals of Inquiry Act, 1921.
186. Food Prices 1924-25
App. 29 Nov 1924. Rep. 23 Apr 1925: 1924-25, Cmd.2390, xiii. Evidence: Non
P.P., Bd. of Trade, 1924; 1925. Est. cost £1,485.
Sir A.C. Geddes; Sir J.L. MacLeod; Sir R.H. Rew; Sir W.H. Peat; Sir H.J.
Mackinder; F.H. Coller; W.T. Layton; G.A. Powell; W.E. Dudley; W. Grant; H.F.
Paul; T.H. Ryland; W.R. Smith; I. Stephenson; Dame H.C.I. Gwynne-Vaughan;
Mrs E. Snowden.
Secretary: T. St. Quintin Hill. Asst. Secs: E.M.H. Lloyd; H.V. Tennant.
To enquire into the conditions prevailing in the wholesale and retail trades in
articles of food of general consumption so far as they affect prices, particularly
having regard to the difference between the prices received by producers and the
prices paid by consumers and to report what action, if any, can usefully be taken.
Rew, Stephenson, Layton and Mrs Snowden signed the report subject to
reservations. Smith and Ryland each wrote a minority report.
187. Indian Currency and Finance 1925-26
App. 25 Aug 1925. Rep. 1 July 1926, Cmd.2687, xii, 501. Evidence: Non P.P.,
India Office, 1926. Est. cost Rs.3,31,000.
E.H. Young; Sir R. Mookerjee; Sir N.H.Y. Warren; Sir R.A. Mant; Sir M.B.
Dadabhoy; Sir H. Strakosch; Sir A.R. Murray; Sir P. Thakurdas; J.C. Coyajee;
Joint Secretaries: G.H. Baxter (India Office) and A. Ayangar (Indian Finance
To examine and report on the Indian Exchange and currency system and
practice, to consider whether any modifications are desirable in the interests of
India, and to make recommendations. (In full.)
Thakurdas signed subject to dissent. Warren attached a note regarding his
position as a Managing Governor of the Imperial Bank of India, stressing that he
had signed the report in a personal capacity and not as a representative of the
188. Coal Industry 1925-26
App. 5 Sept 1925. Rep. 6 March 1926, Cmd.2600, xiv. Evidence: Non P.P.,
Mines Dept., 1926. Est. cost £6,171.
Sir H.L. Samuel; Hon. Sir H.A. Lawrence; Sir W.H. Beveridge; K. Lee.
Secretary: C.S. Hurst. Asst. Sec: F.C. Starling. (Both of Mines Dept.) Assessors:
W. Brace; A.E. Cutforth; W. Gibson; H.M. Hudspeth; C.H. Lander.
To inquire into and report on the economic position of the coal industry and the
conditions affecting it and to make any recommendations for the improvement
thereof. (In full.)
189. Court of Session and Office of Sheriff Principal (Scotland) 1926-27
App. 26 Jan 1926; RSM, sealed at Edinburgh 30 Jan 1926. Rep. 25 Jan 1927,
Cmd.2801, viii. Evidence: Non P.P., Scottish Office, 1927. Est. cost £1,240.
J.A. Clyde; W. Graham (resigned May 1926); Sir J. Adam; J.L. Wark; W. Meff;
W.C. Johnston; J.A. Roxburgh; W.J. Taylor; R.C. Thomson; W.M. Whitelaw.
Secretary: E.E. Parker. (Treasury)
To enquire into the constitution and jurisdiction of the Court of Session; and into
the jurisdiction, powers, duties and functions of the Sheriffs Principal with a view
to ascertaining what changes and improvements might be made.
The report was signed subject to reservations from Meff and Thomson.
190. Agriculture in India 1926-28
App. 23 Apr 1926. Interim reports: 1-12 in 1927, viii, 595; 13-16, abridged
report, and Final Report signed 14 Apr 1928, Cmd.3132, all in 1928, viii.
Evidence: Non P.P., India Office, 1927; 1928. Est. cost Rs.13,72,734
Marquess of Linlithgow; Sir H.S. Lawrence; Sir T. Middleton; Rai Bahadur Sir
L.Ganga Ram (d. 10 July 1927); Sir J. MacKenna; H. Calvert; Raja
S.K.C.G.N.D. Garu; N.N. Gangulee; L.K. Hyder; B.S. Kamat.
Joint Secretaries: J.A. Madan (Indian Civil Service) and F.W.H. Smith (India
Office). Asst. Sec: J.C. McDougall (Indian Agricultural Service). Liaison Officer:
Dr D. Clouston (Agricultural Adviser to Govt. of India).
F. Noyce was appointed Assistant Commissioner during the Commission's work
in England, in place of Raja Garu who had been unable to acompany them to
To examine and report on the present conditions of agricultural and rural
economy in British India, and to make recommendations for the improvement of
agriculture and to promote the welfare and prosperity of the rural population.
191. Cross-River Traffic in London 1926
App. 24 July 1926. Rep. 30 Nov 1926, Cmd.2772, xiii, 217. Evidence: Non P.P.,
Min. of Transport, 1926. Est. cost £2,994.
Viscount Lee of Fareham; Viscount Hambleden; Sir W.H. Dickinson; Sir W.
Plender; Sir L. Weaver; C.E. Inglis.
Secretary: E.G. Howarth. (Bd. of Education; named in Warr.) Asst. Sec: J.R.
To survey the whole problem of cross-river traffic in London; to report what
provision should be made to meet future requirements and, in particular, to
consider the proposals made in connexion with Waterloo and St. Paul's Bridges.
192. Land Drainage 1927
App. 22 March 1927. Rep. 5 Dec 1927, Cmd.2993, x, 1049. Evidence: Non P.P.,
Min. of Agriculture & Fisheries, 1927. Est. cost £885.
Lord Bledisloe; Lord Clinton; Sir G.L. Courthope; Sir A.E. Pritchard; Sir G.H.
Etherton; Sir J.C. Priestley; F.D.W. Drummond; R.R. Robbins; L. Harvey; J.W.
Hills; H.A. Learoyd; W.R. Smith.
Joint Secretaries: H. Meadows and D.B. Toye. Asst. Sec: Hon. A.W.A. Peel.
Lord Clinton resigned 1 July 1927 due to pressure of work following his
appointment as Chairman of the Forestry Commission.
To enquire into the present law relating to Land Drainage in England and Wales
and its administration, and to consider and report whether amendment of the law
was needed, and to make recommendations having regard to all the interests
193. Museums and Galleries 1927-30
App. 1 July 1927. Rep. (1) 1 Sept 1928: 1928-29, Cmd.3192, viii, 699; (2) Pt.I,
20 Sept 1929: 1929-30, Cmd.3401, xvi, 431; Pt.II, 1 Jan 1930, Cmd.3463:
1929-30, xvi, 525. Evidence: Non P.P., Art Collections, 1928; 1929. Est. cost
Viscount D'Abernon; E.E. Charteris; Sir T.L. Heath; Sir L. Earle; Sir R.T.
Glazebrook; Sir G. Macdonald; Sir C. Thomson; Sir W.M. Conway; Sir H.A.
Miers; Sir R.C. Witt; A.E. Cowley.
Secretary: J. Beresford (Treasury). Asst. Sec: J.R. Chambers; succ. by J.H.
Penson, 14 Nov 1928.
The Commission had wide ranging terms of reference: to enquire into and report
on the legal position, organisation, administration, accommodation, structural
condition of the buildings and general cost of the institutions containing the
National Collections in London and Edinburgh and related matters.
The PRO files refer to the need to include provision in the conditions of the
Warrant for the Commissioners to make overseas visits. A previous instance is
cited (no. 136) where the relevant clause was omitted and it had been necessary
to revoke the original Warrant and reappoint the Commission.
194. London Squares 1927-28
App. 5 Aug 1927. Rep. 11 Sept 1928: 1928-29, Cmd.3196, viii, 111. Evidence:
Non P.P., Min. of Health, 1927; 1928. Est. cost £1,051.
Marquess of Londonderry; Sir H.G. Frank; Dame C.B. Bridgeman; Sir G.H.
Duckworth; Sir H.F. New; M.L. Gwyer; C.H. Bird; K.P. Vaughan-Morgan; F.
Briant; F.W. Hobbs; R.C. Norman; A.G. Prichard; H. Snell; C. Thomas.
Secretary: I.F. Armer. (Min. of Health)
To inquire and report on the squares and similar open spaces existing in the area
of the Administrative County of London with special reference to the conditions
on which they are held and used and the desirability of their preservation as open
spaces and to recommend whether any or all of them should be permanently
safeguarded against any use detrimental to their character as open spaces and if
so, by what means and on what terms and conditions. (In full.)
The report was signed subject to reservations by Frank, Prichard and Snell.
(PRO.HLG.10; HO.45/13060; /512024)
195. Indian Education 1927-30
App. 26 Nov 1927. Rep. 12 May 1930: 1929-30, Cmd.3568-9, xi. Other reports:
1929-30, Cmd.3407, x, 535; Cmd.3572, xii. Evidence: Non P.P., 1930. Est. cost
Sir J.A. Simon; Viscount Burnham; Lord Strathcona & Mount Royal; Hon.
E.C.G. Cadogan; S. Walsh; G.R.L. Fox; C.R. Attlee.
Joint Secretaries: J.W. Bhore (resigned Feb 1930) and S.F. Stewart. Asst. Secs:
R.H.A. Carter and E.W. Perry.
A Warrant of 7 Dec 1927 appointed V. Hartshorn in place of Walsh who
resigned. Unlike the other Commissions into Indian affairs this had no Indian
This was a Statutory Commission established by the provisions of Section 84A
of the Government of India Act to inquire into and report on the working of the
system of Government; the growth of education and the development of
representative institutions in British India.
196. Transport 1928-30
App. 4 Aug 1928. Rep. (1) 19 July 1929: 1929-30, Cmd.3365, xvii, 835; (2) 18
Oct 1929: 1929-30, Cmd.3416, xvii, 895; (3) 19 Dec 1930: 1930-31, Cmd.3751,
xvii, 619. Evidence: Non P.P., Min. of Transport, 1928; 1929; 1930; 1931. Est.
Sir A.S.T. Griffith-Boscawen; Marquess of Northampton; Earl of Clarendon;
Hon. J.J. Astor; Sir M.G. Wallace; Sir E.V. Hiley; Sir W.G. Lobjoit; I. Salmon;
H.E. Crawfurd; J. Learmonth; F. Montague; W.R. Smith.
Secretary: R.H. Tolerton. Asst. Sec: A. Spence.
A Warrant of 18 Sept 1929 appointed W. Leach and F.W. Galton in place of
Montague and Smith who had resigned.
To take into consideration the problems arising out of the growth of road traffic
and to report on what measures should be adopted for the control of traffic in
The final report was signed subject to reservations by Lobjoit and Crawfurd; a
memorandum by Crawfurd; and additional recommendations by Donald, Galton
197. Police Powers and Procedure 1928-29
App. 22 Aug 1928. Rep. 16 March 1929: 1928-29, Cmd.3297, ix, 127. Evidence:
Non P.P., HO, 1928; 1929. Est. cost £5,350.
Viscount Lee of Fareham; Lord Ebbisham; Sir H.G. Frank; Dame M.L. Talbot;
Sir R.W.E.L. Poole; J.T. Brownlie; Miss M. Beavan; F. Pick.
Secretary: E.E. Bridges. (Treasury) Asst. Sec: G.D. Kirwan. (Home Office)
To consider the general powers and duties of the police in England and Wales
in the investigation of crimes and offences, including the functions of the
Director of Public Prosecutions and the police respectively, and to make any
One of the primary reasons for establishing the Commission was the widespread
concern over police methods of acquiring evidence. This was specifically
expressed in the Minority Report of the Tribunal of Investigation (1928,
Cmd.3147, xii, 87) into the Police interrogation of Miss Savidge following her
arrest, together with Sir L. Money, on a charge of behaviour 'reasonably likely
to offend against public decency'. The case was subsequently dismissed with
costs against the Police, and questions were raised as to whether the officers
concerned were guilty of perjury or a breach of duty.
198. Labour in India 1929-31
App. 4 July 1929. Rep. 14 March 1931: 1930-31, Cmd.3883, xi, 571. Evidence:
Non P.P., India Office, 1931. Est. costs Rs. 1,050,000 (c.£78,750).
J.H. Whitley; V.S.S. Sastri; Sir E.V. Sassoon; Sir I. Rahimtoola; Sir A.R.
Murray; A.G. Clow; K. Ahmed; G.D. Birla; J. Cliff; N.M. Joshi; D.C. Lall; B.M.
le P. Power.
Joint Secretaries: S. Lall and A. Dibdin. Asst. Sec: J.H. Green.
There were forty-three male and one female Assistant Commissioners, and
nineteen Lady Assessors.
To enquire into and report on the existing conditions of labour in industrial
undertakings and plantations in British India; on the health, efficiency and
standard of living of the workers; and on the relations between employers and
employed; and to make recommendations. (In full.)
Rahimtoola did not sign the report as he had been unable to attend the
proceedings of the Commission following his election as President of the
Legislative Assembly, 17 Jan 1931. The report was signed subject to minutes of
reservation by Sassoon and Ahmed. The other members added comments on
199. Licensing (England and Wales) 1929-31
App. 30 Sept 1929. Rep. 17 Dec 1931: 1931-32, Cmd.3988, xi, 573. Evidence:
Non P.P., HO, 1929; 1930; 1931; 1932. Est. Cost £19,050.
Lord Amulree; Sir J. Pedder; Sir E.F. Stockton; T.G. Arnold; Mrs E. Barton;
W.D. Bentliff; G.A. Bryson; H. Carter; A.A.H. Findlay; J. Fitton; G.A. France;
B.T. Hall (d. 10 Jan 1931); W.L. Hichens; A. Jenkins; J.J. Mallon; J. Morgan;
Miss E. Neville; A. Sherwell; Mrs S.D. Simon; T. Skurray; F.P. Whitbread.
Secretary: M.H. Whitelegge. Asst. Sec: T. Hutson. (Both of Home Office.)
A Warrant of 3 Jan 1930 appointed R.T. Jones in place of Findlay who had
resigned in Dec 1929.
To inquire into the working of the laws relating to the sale and supply of
intoxicating liquors, and into the social and economic aspects of the question, and
to examine and report upon proposals that may be made for amending the law
in England and Wales in the public interest. (In full.)
The majority report was signed subject to reservations by Stockton, Carter, Fitton,
Hichens, Miss Neville and Skurray. There were three separate minority reports
by Mrs Simon; Morgan; and Whitbread.
200. Civil Service 1929-31
App. 28 Oct 1929. Rep. 8 July 1931: 1930-31, Cmd.3909, x, 517. Evidence:
Non P.P., Treasury, 1929; 1930; 1931; 1932. Est. cost £14,155.
Lord Tomlin; Duchess of Atholl; Sir C.T. Needham; Sir H. Sharp; Sir P.R.
Jackson; Sir A. Pownall; J.B. Baillie; W. Cash; F.W. Goldstone; Mrs B.A. Gould;
Miss M.A. Hamilton; Mrs E.M. Lowe; T.E. Naylor; P.J. Pybus; R. Richards; Mrs
Secretary: E.E. Bridges. Asst. Sec: H. Parker. (Both of the Treasury.)
A Warrant of 8 Nov 1929 appointed J. Bromley in place of Naylor who had
To enquire into and report on (a) the structure and organisation of and (b) the
conditions of service in and retirement from the Civil Service. The terms of
reference made specific reference to the position of women civil servants.
201. Licensing Laws in Scotland 1929-31
App. 28 Oct 1929. Rep. 25 May 1931: 1930-31, Cmd.3894, xv, 423. Evidence:
Non P.P., 1930; 1931. Est. cost £4,000. (LP)
Hon. Lord Mackay; Hon. J. Dewar (Lord Forteviot, 1929); Hon. Mrs L.
Forrester-Paton; Sir A.J.W. Lewis; Sir R. Stewart; J.H. Miller; J. Fraser; P.
Chalmers; A.B. Clarke; O. Coyle; Mrs A. Hardie; W. McKim; R.O. Pagan; W.E.
Whyte (ktd. 1930).
Secretary: T.B. Simpson. (Advocate) Asst. Sec: W.H. Blacklock. (Scottish Office)
To investigate the whole field of legislation relating to the sale and supply of
exciseable liquor in Scotland, and to report what amendment in the law, if any,
is desirable in the public interest. (In full.)
The majority report was signed subject to reservations by Miller and McKim; and
the minority Report was signed by the Hon. Mrs Forrester-Paton, Mrs Hardie,
Stewart and Chalmers.